Egypt’s World Cup journey came to a heartbreaking end after a dramatic 3-2 defeat to Argentina. Despite leading 2-0 until the final 10 minutes, the Pharaohs watched the match slip away in a comeback overshadowed by a series of controversial refereeing decisions.
As debate over the officiating continues to dominate headlines and social media, some of football’s biggest players, coaches, pundits, and analysts have shared their thoughts on what unfolded. Here’s what the football world had to say about one of the tournament’s most talked-about matches.
Ian Darke
Football Commentator
Veteran FOX Sports commentator Ian Darke described Argentina as a side that “just won’t go away” after their dramatic comeback. While praising Argentina’s resilience, he also acknowledged the heartbreak for the Pharaohs, calling the late collapse “cruel for Egypt.”
Alan Shearer
Former England striker
Alan Shearer questioned the consistency of the officiating, arguing that if Mostafa Zico’s goal was disallowed after a VAR review for a foul in the build-up, then Argentina’s winner should also have been ruled out because Mohamed Salah was fouled moments before the goal.
Henry Winter
Sports Journalist
English football journalist Henry Winter also questioned the decision to disallow Mostafa Zico’s goal, arguing that VAR had to go back an unusually long way in the build-up to find the foul. He added that had the goal stood, it would have gone down as one of the tournament’s most memorable strikes.
Dale Johnson
Football Correspondent
BBC football officiating correspondent Dale Johnson also highlighted what he saw as an inconsistency in the refereeing. He questioned why Egypt’s goal was ruled out for what appeared to be a minimal foul in the build-up, while similar fouls in other key moments of the match, including before Argentina’s winning goal, were allowed to stand.
Fernando Guerrero Ramírez
Former Football Referee
The most detailed criticism came from Fernando Guerrero, the Mexican referee who served on FIFA’s VAR team at the 2022 World Cup final. Guerrero argued that both the on-field referee and the VAR officials made the wrong decision, insisting there was no foul by the Egyptian attacker on the Argentine defender in the build-up. According to Guerrero, Mostafa Zico’s goal should have stood, adding further weight to the growing criticism of the officiating.
Tomás Roncero
Sports Journalist
Spanish sports journalist Tomás Roncero was among those who criticized the officiating, pointing to what he described as Lautaro Martínez’s repeated aggressive challenges that went unpunished throughout the match. He argued that the World Cup had been “stained,” adding that Egypt did not deserve to exit the tournament under such controversial circumstances.
Luiz Carlos Largo
Sports Commentator
Brazilian sports commentator Luiz Carlos Largo also criticized the officiating, highlighting the moment when Egypt head coach Hossam Hassan made FIFA’s recognized anti-racism “crossed arms” signal to report alleged racist abuse. Largo questioned why the referee ignored the gesture and instead showed Hassan a yellow card, describing the incident as another example of the officials’ mishandling of the match.
José Ramón Fernández Álvarez
Journalist and Sports Commentator
Veteran Mexican sports journalist and commentator José Ramón Fernández compared Mohamed Salah’s smile during the match to Virgil van Dijk’s reaction during the highly controversial Argentina vs. Netherlands quarter-final at the 2022 FIFA World Cup. Fernández suggested history was repeating itself, implying that another Argentina match had become overshadowed by controversial officiating and decisions that sparked widespread debate.
Melissa Reddy
Football Journalist and Author
South African football journalist and author Melissa Reddy also questioned the fairness of the match. Reacting to the controversial officiating, she expressed that after everything that unfolded, anyone who still believes the game is fair must be blissfully ignorant, suggesting the events of the match had seriously undermined confidence in the integrity of the contest.
If these reactions show anything, it’s that Egypt left the World Cup with its heads held high. The fact that respected players, referees, journalists, commentators, and analysts from across the football world all questioned key decisions from the match demonstrates just how widely the controversy was felt.
Regardless of the result, Egypt’s spirited performance against one of the tournament favorites earned global admiration, and for many fans, the Pharaohs will be remembered not for their elimination, but for the resilience and quality they showed until the final whistle.
We Said This: Don’t Miss… Egypt Files Official Complaint Against FIFA Referee: What Happens Now?
